Skip to Content
Menu

Peanut Butter and Jelly Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • Jump to Recipe
  • Save
by: Girl Who Ate Everything
Updated Dec 28, 2014
  • Save
  • Share
  • Jump to Recipe
Peanut butter ice cream is sandwiches between two Granola Thins with some jelly for a refreshing twist on the classic ice cream sandwich.

More About This Recipe

  • I scream, you scream, we all scream for what? ICE CREAM!!!

    Cool and refreshing, nothing beats ice cream on a hot summer day. Whether it’s a reward for your kids or for yourself after a hard day, ice cream is a special treat that I have a hard time turning down.

    I’ve got 5 twists on ice cream that will make sure you never grow tired of your favorite cool treat.

    For recipes, click on underlined title or photo.

    1)  New Recipe! Peanut Butter and Jelly Ice Cream Sandwiches

    These Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches take the idea of a classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich and turn it into ice cream form. How cute are they?

    Just mix some softened vanilla ice cream or frozen yogurt with a little peanut butter and spread it into a baking dish to harden up.

    Once it’s firm, cut it into squares and sandwich your ice cream with a smidgen of jelly in between two Nature Valley Peanut Butter Thins.

    Eat them right away or wrap them in plastic wrap to grab whenever you need a snack.

    For more awesome ideas from Tablespoon's recipe stash, check these out:

    2) No-Fry Fried Ice Cream

    I love fried ice cream but not all the calories that are in it. This “fake-out” fried ice cream still has all of the crunch and cinnamon goodness that the traditional ice cream has but without all of the fuss of frying.

    3) S’mores Ice Cream

    Bring the campfire to you with this S’mores Ice Cream. No ice cream machine needed to create creamy, s'moresy (yes, I think I just made up that word) ice cream.

    4) Banana Split Ice Cream Pie

    A banana split turned into a pie…yes, please! Yum, yum…give me some.

    5) Cookie Dough Ice Cream Dessert

    Although I love ice cream, cookies and cookie dough may hold the title for my favorite dessert. So put them together and it’s pretty much game over, I surrender.

    So many great ideas and so little time to eat them!!!

    Christy joined the Tablespoon team to share her recipes and inspire family food fun. Watch her Tablespoon member profile for great new recipes!

    How do you like to eat your ice cream? In a cone, bowl or shake?

Peanut Butter and Jelly Ice Cream Sandwiches

  • Prep Time 35 min
  • Total 50 min
  • Servings 15
  • Ingredients 5
  • Save
  • Share
  • Print
  • Keep Screen On

Ingredients

  • 1 pint vanilla ice cream or frozen yogurt
  • 1/2 cup peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup strawberry or grape jelly
  • 30 Nature Valley™ Peanut Butter Granola Thins
  • Wax paper

Instructions

  • Step 
    1
    Let ice cream soften on the counter for 5-10 minutes. Scoop into a small bowl and add the peanut butter. Mix thoroughly with a spoon until combined.
  • Step 
    2
    Line a 9X9 baking dish with wax paper on the bottom. Spoon the peanut butter ice cream into the dish and spread evenly. Add another layer of wax paper and press on top. Freeze ice cream for at least 25-30 minutes or until firm. You can freeze it longer if you would like.
  • Step 
    3
    Before you remove the ice cream from the freezer, prep your sandwiches. Remove granola thins from packages. Spread about 1 teaspoon of jelly on the peanut butter side of one granola thin. Repeat 15 times leaving the other 15 granola thins plain.
  • Step 
    4
    Once ice cream is firm, remove from pan and place on the counter. Remove the top layer of wax paper and cut into 16 even pieces the size of your Granola Thins. Quickly place a frozen ice cream square on on one granola thin with jelly and top with a plain granola thin. Return immediately to the freezer and continue making the rest.
  • Step 
    5
    You can eat them immediately or after they have firmed up a bit. Wrap in plastic wrap individually so they can be grabbed as snacks later.

Nutrition

No nutrition information available for this recipe
© 2025 ®/TM General Mills All Rights Reserved